Metal vs. Shingle Roof – Which Is Worthy of Your Investment?

16 May Metal vs. Shingle Roof – Which Is Worthy of Your Investment?

It’s time to get a new roof, and you have a big decision to make. Should you go with a shingle or metal roof? Once you compare the two, you’ll know which one is right for your home. Then, you can move forward with a new roof.
Let’s see how the two options stack up in all the important categories.


When looking at a shingle versus a metal roof, you need to consider the durability. After all, the weather can get a little crazy on the East Coast, and you want a roof that can stand up to everything from high winds to torrential downpours.

That’s why metal roofing is growing increasingly popular in Massachusetts and Connecticut. A standing seam metal roof easily holds up against the elements, no matter how wild it gets. These roofs even stand up to fires. Because they are so durable, many insurance companies reduce premiums for homeowners that have metal roofs. The companies know they will have fewer claims, so they pass the savings onto the homeowners.

On the other hand, bad weather can destroy shingle roofs. Go around your neighborhood after a downpour or high winds. You’ll probably see a few roofs missing a shingle or two. That’s par for the course when you choose a shingle roof. That’s why there’s a lot more maintenance involved with shingle roofs.

Metal roofs win this category, hands down. If you want a durable roof with low maintenance, the choice is clear. You need to go with a metal roof.


When you have a roof installed, you want it to last. You want to put it on and forget about it for the rest of your life.
If you go with shingles, that probably won’t happen. Asphalt shingles typically last for 15 to 30 years. That means if you get a roof when your first child is born, you can expect to replace it when he or she is in college. Talk about stressful.

You can send the grandkids off to college before replacing a standing seam metal roof, though. These roofs typically last 50 years or more. You can put your roof on and forget about it for decades. In fact, the roof just might last your entire lifetime.

It’s clear that metal roofing wins this round, as well. These roofs last decades longer, so if longevity is important to you, you need to choose a standing seam metal roof.


If you’ve seen one shingle roof, you’ve seen them all. They pretty much look the same, and that look is pretty boring. On the other hand, you can step outside of the box with an architectural metal roof. Manufacturers make metal roofs that look like various materials, such as wood, stone, and clay. Many homeowners enjoy expressing themselves with metal roofs.

The metal roof is the clear winner once again. You can get as creative as you want with an architectural metal roof.
Home Value

As a homeowner, you want to increase your home’s value as much as you can. After all, your home is your biggest asset. You might not realize you can increase your home’s value when you get a new roof. Well, at least you can if you choose correctly.

Metal roofing increases the value of the home, and not just a little bit. It can increase the home’s value by to 80 percent of roof’s cost. It is rare to get that type of return on investment when upgrading your home.
On the other hand, a shingle roof doesn’t add to the home’s value. That means the metal roof is the clear winner once again.

Energy Efficiency

The summers get awfully hot, and you put a great deal of demand on your air conditioner. You might not realize that choosing the right roof can actually reduce your unit’s workload.

While shingle roofs let the heat in, a standing seam metal roof reflects the sun away from your home. That means less heat makes its way into your house. A metal roof can reduce the peak cooling demand by as much as 15 percent and can save you up to 25 percent on your energy costs.

The metal roof wins again. It’s the right choice if you want an energy-efficient roof.


This category is a little trickier. On the surface, asphalt roofs are cheaper than metal roofs are, but once you dig a little bit deeper, you’ll see that metal roofs are actually the affordable option.

Metal roofs do cost more to install than asphalt roofs, but over the course of 60 years, a metalroof ends up costing around a third of what you would spend on an asphalt roof. Since metal roofs last so much longer, they save homeowners money in the long run. When you factor in additional economic incentives, these roofs are practically a steal.

Once again, the metal roof is the clear winner.


When you’re nestled in your home, you don’t want to think about your roof. You want peace and quiet, without loud sounds when it rains. Both asphalt and metal roofs are quiet, so you won’t have to worry about excess noise getting in the way of enjoying yourself at home. The idea that metal roofs are louder than asphalt roofs is nothing but a myth. Your metal roofing installer will use insulation to muffle the sounds. That means you can watch movies, relax, or fall asleep during a rainstorm, regardless of the roof you have.

The two options are a draw in this category.

Which One Is Right for You?

Going with a metal roof just makes sense. From the looks to the cost savings, it’s clear that a standing seam metal roof is the right option for your home. If you’re interested in metal roofing in Connecticut or Massachusetts, contact us today. We are professional and reliable, and we offer financing. With our help, you can enjoy all of these amazing benefits that come with a metal roof.